Quick Answer:
Detailed Answer:
Question: Who f r o m among traditionists have confirmed accuracy of chain of transmission of Manzelat tradition?
Answer: Referring to the tradition books, we find that many traditionists have confirmed accuracy of Manzelat tradition. Hereunder, we will refer to some of them:
1- Abou Issa Tarmazi: Following narrating the tradition, he says:
هذا حدیث حسن صحیح
This tradition is good and correct. (1)
2- Ebne Timyeh: Following narrating the tradition, he says:
انّ هذا الحدیث صحیح بلا ریب ثبت فی الصحیحین وغیرهما
Surely this tradition is correct and has been registered in the two Sahih and other books. (2)
3- Ebne Abdolbar: Following narrating the tradition, he says:
وهو من اثبت الآثار واصحّها
This tradition is one of the most stable and correct works. (3)
4- Sheikh Abdolhaq: Following narrating the tradition, he says:
انّ الأئمة متفقة على صحة هذا الحدیث
Surely Imams of tradition agree on the accuracy of this tradition. (4)
5- Ganji Shafeei: He claims for unanimity on accuracy of tradition. (5)
6- Mazzi: He has called this tradition one of the most stable and correct.(6)
7- Hakem Neishabouri: He confirms accuracy of tradition. (7)
8- Yafeei: He confirms accuracy of tradition. (8)
9- Baghavi: He confirms accuracy of tradition. (9)
10- Abou Naeim Isfahani: He confirms accuracy of tradition. (10)
11- Zahabi (11), (12)
1- الجامع الصحیح, vol. 5, page 640, item 3730
2- منهاج السنه, vo. 7, page 320
3- الاستیعاب, vol. 3, page 1097
4- شرح المشکاه, “Virtues of Ali (a.s.)” chapter
5- کفایه الطالب
6- تهذیب الکمال, vol. 20, page 483
7- المستدرک علی الصحیحین, vol. 3, page 109
8- مرآة الجنان, vol. 1, page 109
9- مصابیح السنة, vol. 2, page 275
10- حلیة الاولیاء
11- تلخیص المستدرک
12- Ali Asghar Rezvani, Imamology and reply to questions (2), page 224
No feedback yet